MKSGR:
bhnyc:
The idea that you are "faster" in a car because of PDK vs. manual does not compute for me. Lap times are a matter of relativity. Are you faster than your last lap. If you have different equipment then you have a different car and of course different cars are faster than other cars. Not like GT3 is the fastest car. You can always by a faster car. So those who argue that they should get the fastest version of a car, I would argue that you can always buy a faster car. For me the argument is are you faster than your last lap given the equipment you chose to have. Be that PDK or manual. If you are a racer, than that is a different argument as you are in a specific class of car (but you still aren't in PDK - )
This argument has a certain logic
It has but it misses a point: That a manual equipped GT3 will be always slower than a PDK equipped PDK with the same driver, professional or amateur and probably much slower with an amateur driver because amateur drivers profit from PDK. Actually, many sports car companies work on semi-automatic systems and even ESP setups which make even professionals faster and I'm not kidding.
Take the 991 Carrera S for example: I heard that a professional driver with ESP off does practically the same time with ESP turned on (Sport Plus mode) on the track. This is amazing and speaks for the engineering skills of the people involved.
Maybe we should put this in a different perspective: Imagine you are at a driving event and at some point, even if it is a driver ed event, there is some sort of competition with time taking. So here's my point: Do you want to be the fastest or one of the fastest or do you want to enjoy yourself? You can't have both as an amateur driver because achieving the best or the second best time requires very good driving skills AND a perfect technical setup, there is also always somebody in the group who is a semi-pro or a former pro. So from a group of 10 cars, you would be the 5th or 6th or maybe the 9th because all these cars had PDK and you had manual (same car and power). Would you care? I bet you would. Just an example.
You can have fun with PDK too. If you cannot use the clutch, try to do something else, like learning to drive a cleaner line or learn braking (amazing how many good drivers actually lack braking skills) or how to use the steering to your advantages or whatever. I understand when someone like Walter Röhrl tells me that he prefers manual over PDK (which may not even be true) but most amateurs and even semi-pros have still so much to learn and operating a clutch is only a small part of it. You can still shift...using the paddles, does it really matter that here is no stick?! So anyone can have amazing fun using PDK in the GT3 but you just need to wipe off this "manual is manly" or "manual is for pros" prejudice image from your brain. My 80 year old mother knows how to drive stick, this is nothing special in Europe. Get over it.
A last word on PDK and why many who have it on their cars may criticize it: With PDK, it is pretty easy to drive in auto mode only, actually the tentation is very high. I use my Panamera Turbo S in PDK auto mode only, maybe because I am too lazy to shift or maybe because I hate the buttons (I do not have paddles) but the point is, it is more "convenient". Sometimes, I switch to manual mode and I really like it but then, I cannot concentrate as much on steering and braking as I do with the auto mode. I can shift but I can still learn a lot about my limits when it comes to controlling/handling the car, so manual shifting is actually distracting. It is difficult to explain but for me, the pleasure of driving manual has gone, I kind of like the challenge to do everything in auto mode, perfecting my steering, braking and so on. At some point, this is very fascinating because belive me, if I had to shift, I could never do what I do with PDK auto mode. We are talking amateurs and semi-pros here, not professionals.
I get it: You want to shift manually because it is fun. Especially on a Cab or Roadster, I can really rely to this. If you want to achieve the fastest possible time though, manual is not what you are looking for. Unless you are a pro and even then, it could be difficult. You don't want to know who had difficulties to follow me in my 997 Turbo RUF 550 and I had...Tiptronic. Not even PDK. In the end, the driver is the one who drives the car, so driver skills count most.
Maybe we can agree on one thing: In the end, driving fun is defined by personal preference, driving skill, certain feelings and of course some prejudice. Humans are different and they prefer different things. I can live with that and I hope you can too.
--
RC (Germany) - Rennteam Editor Porsche Panamera Turbo S, Cayenne GTS (958), 991 Turbo S (Oct. 5th), BMW X3 35d (2013)