Yo, David - welcome to rennteam mate!
Ok I was trying not to post here but my resolve has folded... First let me hold my hand up and say that I am probably the one who is giving David the "feedback" that M-DCT might be tough to live with as we are good friends in real life and so have been talking a lot about it recently following his test drive. My comments are however directed towards PDK, not M-DCT as I am a little worried that it might be more like PDK than SMGII, which we both agree is fantastic.
So I reckon the question you really need to be asking on this Porsche forum to put my verbal comments in context is how does M-DCT compare to PDK?? Is it very similar to PDK and if it does differ then exactly how does it and in what way is it either better or worse?
Some here might remember that I had a very bad experience with PDK. I had a test drive (mainly out on twisty roads) and I fell head over heals in love with it, thinking it would bring back all the thrills of my 4yrs of happy E46 M3 SMGII ownership. I thought it made the 997 a better drivers car, so much so that it was the one of the main reasons I then quickly sold my 997.1 man C2S to get a lovely new 997.2 PDK C2S. Within 6 weeks I had become so disgruntled with PDK alone that I had to sell it and suffered a big financial loss in doing so. The problem I had was down to it feeling like an automatic when driving around town - which at the end of the day is the majority of my driving.
That said just because I dislike PDK so much now doesnt mean to say that anybody else would, indeed Im pretty sure PDK will have more fans here than haters. A lot of my driving time is in town and PDK in my opinion feels like nothing more than a swanky automatic in heavy traffic and I hated it for that very reason. SMGII always left me feeling like I was driving a manual even in traffic as it required skill to change smoothly and never attempted to 2nd guess those gears automatically for you when in M mode. Another thing was the way PDK creeps forward in traffic just like an auto - arrgggh! I will admit that out on the open roads PDK is everybit as good as SMGII, indeed it is quite probably a lot better. There is no doubt in my mind that the way that PDK changes gear is mindblowing when driving fast, - but in the end due to my driving profile the 90% bad times were more important to me than the 10% good times.
So the crux of the question here in my mind is if M-DCT is more like PDK or SMGII? If the answer is that is it more like PDK than SMGII then Im worried and I reckon I personally wouldnt be able to live with it! If the answer is that its more like SMGII or it is different to both then - hurray, all sounds good, I'm in!!! Hopefully somebody here can provide some techincal and objective feedback on how all three perform on both the twisties and when stuck in traffic. Im afraid I have never driven M-DCT so I have no idea and I fully admit that I am left somewhat rather tainted against all semi-automatics now after my bad PDK experience, even after such great motoring times with SMGII. I'd still buy a SMGII car at the drop of a hat right now, but I wouldnt have a PDK car if you gave it to me. Where is M-DCT on that scale though?
Anyway - I really dont want to sound like Im trying to put you off M-DCT mate cos Im desperatley trying not to do that, I'm just trying to share the wisdom of my "PDK mistake with you" and how it had me fooled on a test drive. The M3 is a truely stonking and very very desireable car and if M-DCT is unlike PDK then I wish I had driven one a few years back as I would probably have bought one and subsquently never ended up wasting my money on PDK! haha... Good words of wisdom above already that only you can make up your own mind and besides who cares what I think. Even if I drive M-DCT and dont like for any reason it then that doesnt matter one bit as long as you love it. I'm pretty sure most people will probably prefer PDK to SMGII anyway, but I didnt that's all...
Just ignore my anti-PDK prattle, Im just sore about the whole thing! I certainly dont mean to be introducing doubt in your mind, I feel like Im doing more harm than good passing on my expereince of PDK to ya...
Get that E92 M3 DCT bought and lets have a blast around town together, errrr I mean on the twisties!