For me The Boxster was and IS A WINNER from the beginning !!! Styling + Handling + Performance... !!! AND I love those summerevening OPEN TOP drives, for me and IMHO NO Cayman or other Coupe can beat that feeling !!!
There are better sports cars than the Cayman AND the Boxster obviously. But the Boxster is a special combination of fun and sportiness, not too serious but not too much of a sissy either.