Crown

Board: Other Sports Cars Language: English Region: Worldwide Share/Save/Bookmark Close

Forum - Thread


    AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Seeing as today is AMV8 day, I thought everyone would like to see these scans from this weeks Autocar magazine. Got to say, as much as I love the 911, I'd rather have the AMV8 on my driveway. If only I was on the waiting list and had the Pounds80k to pay for it





    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Thanks for posting...good read... it'd be a least a month before we get that issue here!!

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    Atlantis said:
    If only I was on the waiting list and had the Pounds80k to pay for it




    Well I've got one bit of that right - I'll let you guess which!! Best go buying those lottery tickets now....

    Interestingly in one of the weeklies (Autocar or Auto Express) they are saying the waiting list may drop. Due to lack of demand in Europe they may put more allocation the UK dealers way.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    Rich C (UK) said:
    Quote:
    Atlantis said:
    If only I was on the waiting list and had the Pounds80k to pay for it




    Well I've got one bit of that right - I'll let you guess which!! Best go buying those lottery tickets now....

    Interestingly in one of the weeklies (Autocar or Auto Express) they are saying the waiting list may drop. Due to lack of demand in Europe they may put more allocation the UK dealers way.



    Indeed, it a fantastic car, but at Pounds15,000 over the Carrera S, it's hefty price to pay for exclusivity and name when you know the car is dynamically inferior.
    Would be interesting to see what happens to orders in a couple of years.
    For now though, you're all good, you could potentially enjoy one year or Aston V8 motoring almost for free!!!

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    I'd definately choose the 997. I don't really understand all the ga-ga over the v8 Vantage, just looks like a smaller db9.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    Danny G said:
    , just looks like a smaller db9.



    and that's a bad thing??

    For a total objective opinion I probably agree that the 997 is the 'better' choice - but with cars like these when did we ever decide objectively?

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    I would buy the AM all day long over the 997

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Thanks Atlantis.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    Rich C (UK) said:
    Quote:
    Danny G said:
    , just looks like a smaller db9.



    and that's a bad thing??

    For a total objective opinion I probably agree that the 997 is the 'better' choice - but with cars like these when did we ever decide objectively?



    Nothing, but the DB9, AMV8 and Vantage are all pretty much the same, design wise. There is no real philosophy behind building the AMV8 in my view other than trying to appeal to a 'poorer' demographic.

    For instance, each car in Ferrari's linup has a different appeal regardless of price. The f430 is mid engine sports, the 575 Maranello is the GT car and the 612 is the 4seater large GT (enzo not included, too exotic and limited). Most people I would think would choose an above model on what the car offers, not what they could afford. Totally different with the Astons which are 1 sausage, 3 different sizes.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    That is very true, which is why the smart Aston to buy is the V8.

    I'd be pretty pissed if I was a Vanquish S owner, apart from the V12 credential, you have a car that is over twice the price, it's slower, it's not as pretty, it's awful on the inside, and it's not as good to drive, go figure...
    The DB9, although very similar in looks (Which is not great for it, but good for the V8), is more of a long distance GT.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    My wife and I think the review indicated an impressive showing for the Vantage. Even though saddled with a driver unfamiliar with the AMV8 and in a stock configuration, it was competitive with the Carrera S. The Porsche had the non-real world advantages of a specialist driver, unusually low suspension, and ceramic brakes. Imagine how much closer it would have been if it were a more typical 997 configuration and both drivers were equally adept with their vehicles (and their vehicle's left/right side driving configuration).

    Even then, it doesn't matter which wins so long as it is close. As my wife the family Porsche enthusiast points out, they emphasized things we never actually do with our vehicles. On our normal rough roads, her new Carrera 4S is rather an uncomfortable daily driver over the highways she travels. The Porsche interior finish isn't as high and the cabin noise level is fatiguing. Even worse, Porsche's insistence that numerous interior and window rattles are normal in a new vehicle doesn't help. She gives the absolute handling thumbs up to Porsche, but that isn't enough to satisfy her. Her car needs to be more than just a driving instrument.

    She wants the Vantage's better interior, sound system, gorgeous looks, and uniqueness. She has me feel the leather in the shifter shroud in her new Carrera 4S that she unaffectionately calls the "Rattle Bucket."

    "See how thin it is here and how the doors feel like plastic even though it is all leather? When I was in the DB9 and especially the Vanquish, the leather felt thicker and richer, like there was a whole cow!"

    I hadn't noticed myself, but she DOES notice those things and she wants that luxurious feel but also drivability like a Porsche.

    Now there is a viable alternative to Porsche that delivers (for only a marginally higher cost) a luxury sports motoring experience. She estimates that she'd only lose the 5% of performance she NEVER uses anyway. So, in reality she won't give up any real driving ability, but instead gain a better ride for our rough roads, a lot more panache, and loads better style.

    Thinking ahead, I had paid to put her on our AM dealer's AMV8 list some time ago. My wife, a once dedicated Porsche enthusiast eagerly wants to switch to an Aston. It's going to be a long wait until delivery next year. This review only fueled the desire.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    I don't understand the price of the Vanquish at all. It's got a more muscular look than a "plain" DB-9 but how do they justify the extra $100k? You could have a GT-3 in the garage next to the DB-9 for the price of a Vanquish.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    LowPolarMoment said:
    I don't understand the price of the Vanquish at all. It's got a more muscular look than a "plain" DB-9 but how do they justify the extra $100k? You could have a GT-3 in the garage next to the DB-9 for the price of a Vanquish.


    People who buy cars like that do it precisely because it's that expensive. It guarantees exclusivity and snob appeal. I also find it ironic that the cheapest Aston Martin is also the best one...

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    Guy Kuo said:
    My wife and I think the review indicated an impressive showing for the Vantage. Even though saddled with a driver unfamiliar with the AMV8 and in a stock configuration, it was competitive with the Carrera S. The Porsche had the non-real world advantages of a specialist driver, unusually low suspension, and ceramic brakes. Imagine how much closer it would have been if it were a more typical 997 configuration and both drivers were equally adept with their vehicles (and their vehicle's left/right side driving configuration).

    Even then, it doesn't matter which wins so long as it is close. As my wife the family Porsche enthusiast points out, they emphasized things we never actually do with our vehicles. On our normal rough roads, her new Carrera 4S is rather an uncomfortable daily driver over the highways she travels. The Porsche interior finish isn't as high and the cabin noise level is fatiguing. Even worse, Porsche's insistence that numerous interior and window rattles are normal in a new vehicle doesn't help. She gives the absolute handling thumbs up to Porsche, but that isn't enough to satisfy her. Her car needs to be more than just a driving instrument.

    She wants the Vantage's better interior, sound system, gorgeous looks, and uniqueness. She has me feel the leather in the shifter shroud in her new Carrera 4S that she unaffectionately calls the "Rattle Bucket."

    "See how thin it is here and how the doors feel like plastic even though it is all leather? When I was in the DB9 and especially the Vanquish, the leather felt thicker and richer, like there was a whole cow!"

    I hadn't noticed myself, but she DOES notice those things and she wants that luxurious feel but also drivability like a Porsche.

    Now there is a viable alternative to Porsche that delivers (for only a marginally higher cost) a luxury sports motoring experience. She estimates that she'd only lose the 5% of performance she NEVER uses anyway. So, in reality she won't give up any real driving ability, but instead gain a better ride for our rough roads, a lot more panache, and loads better style.

    Thinking ahead, I had paid to put her on our AM dealer's AMV8 list some time ago. My wife, a once dedicated Porsche enthusiast eagerly wants to switch to an Aston. It's going to be a long wait until delivery next year. This review only fueled the desire.



    One of the best comparisons I have read in a long time!

    BTW when figuring cost particularly in the US, one cannot ignore the depreciation of the Porsche. Certainly the AM will retain its value much better.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:

    "See how thin it is here and how the doors feel like plastic even though it is all leather? When I was in the DB9 and especially the Vanquish, the leather felt thicker and richer, like there was a whole cow!"



    And if Porsche puts a boatload of leather in their cars, customers will complain it gets too GTish.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    Guy Kuo said:
    My wife and I think the review indicated an impressive showing for the Vantage. Even though saddled with a driver unfamiliar with the AMV8 and in a stock configuration, it was competitive with the Carrera S. The Porsche had the non-real world advantages of a specialist driver, unusually low suspension, and ceramic brakes. Imagine how much closer it would have been if it were a more typical 997 configuration and both drivers were equally adept with their vehicles (and their vehicle's left/right side driving configuration).

    Even then, it doesn't matter which wins so long as it is close. As my wife the family Porsche enthusiast points out, they emphasized things we never actually do with our vehicles. On our normal rough roads, her new Carrera 4S is rather an uncomfortable daily driver over the highways she travels. The Porsche interior finish isn't as high and the cabin noise level is fatiguing. Even worse, Porsche's insistence that numerous interior and window rattles are normal in a new vehicle doesn't help. She gives the absolute handling thumbs up to Porsche, but that isn't enough to satisfy her. Her car needs to be more than just a driving instrument.

    She wants the Vantage's better interior, sound system, gorgeous looks, and uniqueness. She has me feel the leather in the shifter shroud in her new Carrera 4S that she unaffectionately calls the "Rattle Bucket."

    "See how thin it is here and how the doors feel like plastic even though it is all leather? When I was in the DB9 and especially the Vanquish, the leather felt thicker and richer, like there was a whole cow!"

    I hadn't noticed myself, but she DOES notice those things and she wants that luxurious feel but also drivability like a Porsche.

    Now there is a viable alternative to Porsche that delivers (for only a marginally higher cost) a luxury sports motoring experience. She estimates that she'd only lose the 5% of performance she NEVER uses anyway. So, in reality she won't give up any real driving ability, but instead gain a better ride for our rough roads, a lot more panache, and loads better style.

    Thinking ahead, I had paid to put her on our AM dealer's AMV8 list some time ago. My wife, a once dedicated Porsche enthusiast eagerly wants to switch to an Aston. It's going to be a long wait until delivery next year. This review only fueled the desire.



    May want to drive a DB9 for an extended drive, before assuming "grass is greener" in AM world...and compare to 997S w/full leather. May want to look at DB9's key fob (and try to differentiate it from any Ford's); chk how "well-built" the turn signal stalk feels; look at "quality" of rear-view mirror; try to find interior storage for stuff like sunglasses/garage remotes/water bottle/miscell stuff; chk the legroom for the front passenger; listen for rattles/squeaks; eval traction of car in simple, dry urban acceleration situations; ask DB9 owners re: how reliable car has been; etc....results may surprise you...

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    brunner said:
    Quote:
    "See how thin it is here and how the doors feel like plastic even though it is all leather? When I was in the DB9 and especially the Vanquish, the leather felt thicker and richer, like there was a whole cow!"


    And if Porsche puts a boatload of leather in their cars, customers will complain it gets too GTish.


    ..and the whole cow makes the Vanquish weighs 1000 pounds more than a 997.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    The Vantage is premiering here in Seattle at the end of this month. By that time, she'll have a brand new 2006 997 to replace her C4S "rattle bucket." (No thanks to Porsche NA failing to stand behind the vehicle, but kudos to the Barrier Motors dealership for finally agreeing to make the replacement Porsche less costly to us.)

    She's in the best of circumstances - able to choose whether to keep a brand new 997 with Sports chrono and adaptive seating or go for the AMV8. What a delightful dilemma!

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    LowPolarMoment said:
    I don't understand the price of the Vanquish at all. It's got a more muscular look than a "plain" DB-9 but how do they justify the extra $100k? You could have a GT-3 in the garage next to the DB-9 for the price of a Vanquish.



    Keep in mind where Aston Martin is coming from. When market positioning of Vanquish (oldest model in the AM range) was fixed, AM was probably making less than 2000 cars/year.(I haven't researched the statistics, but I won't be too far out). Low prod numbers = high unit costs = high prices.

    AM now has ambitions to increase production considerably, so they have to considerably reduce prices to move the metal. You see the result of this change of strategy in the pricing of the newer models, DB8 and DB9.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    fritz said:
    Quote:
    LowPolarMoment said:
    I don't understand the price of the Vanquish at all. It's got a more muscular look than a "plain" DB-9 but how do they justify the extra $100k? You could have a GT-3 in the garage next to the DB-9 for the price of a Vanquish.



    Keep in mind where Aston Martin is coming from. When market positioning of Vanquish (oldest model in the AM range) was fixed, AM was probably making less than 2000 cars/year.(I haven't researched the statistics, but I won't be too far out). Low prod numbers = high unit costs = high prices.

    AM now has ambitions to increase production considerably, so they have to considerably reduce prices to move the metal. You see the result of this change of strategy in the pricing of the newer models, DB8 and DB9.



    Fair points, fritz. However, I'm amazed that AM is pricing AMV8 at about 20% above 997S.....should be intriguing to see how many units they can sell w/that pricing and what resale value will be in this relatively price-sensitive part of the car mkt.

    The air thins out quickly north of $100K...let's not forget what a struggle Maser is facing to sell cars (F dealers are having to force-feed Maser sales by tying them to 430 sales)....and Lambo's much-anticipated Gallardo turned out to be a weak response to the 360 or 430 (one can negotiate hefty discounts/expect hefty depreciation on new G's....don't know if Lambo is able to sell as many G's as originally planned)

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    The car is apparently quite loud which is great! Is it possible to switch off the valve in the exhaust that creates this when you're in residential neighborhoods?

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    birdness said:
    The car is apparently quite loud which is great! Is it possible to switch off the valve in the exhaust that creates this when you're in residential neighborhoods?



    If the exhaust on the Vantage works the same way as on the Vanquish, the valve is open at idle, to give you a great idle sound. Then it closes at around 1000 rpm and stays closed until 3-4000 rpm when it opens again. Unless you floor it, then it stays open all the time. So waking up your neighbours shouldn't be a problem unless you drive hard.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    I have read all the reviews on the AMV8 and have actually put in a deposit for late 2006 or early 2007 delivery. All the reviews say the same thing: almost as good as a 911 Carrera S (although sometimes the 911 is given an unfair advantage like ceramic brakes and lowered sports suspension)
    Why choose an AMV8 then? The main reason is that the 911 is missing the mystique that characterizes the Aston. I live in a large Canadian city and I can honestly say that I have seen less than 5 Astons in my lifetime. Talk about exclusivity!! I can actually remember the different times that I saw each one(this coming from a Ferrari fan). Porsche's, no matter how good they are, are just too common to be appreciated. The looks and the interior finish on the Aston just leave the 911 in its dust.The AMV8, by all accounts, is an excellent car and gives the best Porsche ever made a good run for its money. I am more than happy to trade a slightly mechanically inferior car (which I would never notice in real life), for everything the Aston gives me; I am getting exclusivity, history, beauty, power, grace, and a state of the art sports car. This is the best car Aston has ever made. I think it sounds much better to say that I drive an Aston Martin than saying I drive a Porsche. I am counting the days till I get mine.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    I just noticed Autocar misspelled "Carrera" in the data panel...how in the world did that get through?

    Gary

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    tdf360 said:
    I just noticed Autocar misspelled "Carrera" in the data panel...how in the world did that get through?

    Gary



    Maybe for the same reason that most of the text got through.

    Re: AMV8 vs 911 Autocar Scans

    Quote:
    Al Pettee said:
    Quote:
    tdf360 said:
    I just noticed Autocar misspelled "Carrera" in the data panel...how in the world did that get through? Gary


    Maybe for the same reason that most of the text got through.

    LOL. Good one Al.

     
    Edit

    Forum

    Board Subject Last post Rating Views Replies
    Porsche Sticky SUN'S LAST RUN TO WILSON, WY - 991 C2S CAB LIFE, END OF AN ERA (Part II) 4/17/24 7:16 AM
    GnilM
    781904 1798
    Porsche Sticky Welcome to Rennteam: Cars and Coffee... (photos) 4/7/24 11:48 AM
    Boxster Coupe GTS
    442837 565
    Porsche Sticky OFFICIAL: Cayman GT4 RS (2021) 5/12/23 12:11 PM
    W8MM
    263486 288
    Porsche Sticky OFFICIAL: Porsche 911 (992) GT3 RS - 2022 3/12/24 8:28 AM
    DJM48
    261900 323
    Porsche Sticky The new Macan: the first all-electric SUV from Porsche 1/30/24 9:18 AM
    RCA
    85979 45
    Porsche Sticky OFFICIAL: Taycan 2024 Facelift 3/15/24 1:23 PM
    CGX car nut
    6008 50
    Porsche The moment I've been waiting for... 2/1/24 7:01 PM
    Pilot
     
     
     
     
     
    881661 1364
    Porsche 992 GT3 7/23/23 7:01 PM
    Grant
    819643 3868
    Porsche GT4RS 4/21/24 11:50 AM
    mcdelaug
    392695 1454
    Porsche Welcome to the new Taycan Forum! 2/10/24 4:43 PM
    nberry
    392437 1526
    Others Tesla 2 the new thread 12/13/23 2:48 PM
    CGX car nut
    375787 2401
    Porsche Donor vehicle for Singer Vehicle Design 7/3/23 12:30 PM
    Porker
    369508 797
    Porsche Red Nipples 991.2 GT3 Touring on tour 4/11/24 12:32 PM
    Ferdie
    290129 668
    Porsche Collected my 997 GTS today 10/19/23 7:06 PM
    CGX car nut
     
     
     
     
     
    261989 812
    Lambo Huracán EVO STO 7/30/23 6:59 PM
    mcdelaug
    240846 346
    Lotus Lotus Emira 6/25/23 2:53 PM
    Enmanuel
    231404 101
    Others Corvette C8 10/16/23 3:24 PM
    Enmanuel
    221695 488
    Others Gordon Murray - T.50 11/22/23 10:27 AM
    mcdelaug
    169995 387
    Porsche Back to basics - 996 GT3 RS 6/11/23 5:13 PM
    CGX car nut
    141751 144
    BMW M 2024 BMW M3 CS Official Now 12/29/23 9:04 AM
    RCA
    118288 303
    Motor Sp. 2023 Formula One 12/19/23 5:38 AM
    WhoopsyM
    109491 685
    Porsche 2022 992 Safari Model 3/7/24 4:22 PM
    WhoopsyM
    84678 239
    AMG Mercedes-Benz W124 500E aka Porsche typ 2758 2/23/24 10:03 PM
    blueflame
    75448 297
    Porsche 992 GT3 RS 3/3/24 7:22 PM
    WhoopsyM
    54309 314
    Motor Sp. Porsche 963 3/16/24 9:27 PM
    WhoopsyM
    25532 237
    Ferrari Ferrari 296 GTB (830PS, Hybrid V6) 1/21/24 4:29 PM
    GT-Boy
    21240 103
    BMW M 2022 BMW M5 CS 4/8/24 1:43 PM
    Ferdie
    19600 140
    AMG G63 sold out 9/15/23 7:38 PM
    Nico997
    16659 120
    AMG [2022] Mercedes-AMG SL 4/23/24 1:24 PM
    RCA
    13939 225
    Motor Sp. 24-Hour race Nürburgring 2018 5/25/23 10:42 PM
    Grant
    11301 55
    126 items found, displaying 1 to 30.