For what it's worth, I spent a lot of time test driving (multiple drives) in a 996, and I decided on a 987S. I felt that I shouldhave preferred the 911, but I didn't. I think I'm happier with the chuckability of mid-engines. The Boxster S felt like a perfect leap for my from my Lotus Elise - fairly similar feel being mid-engined, just much meatier. Haven't tried a Vette, but have had a number of TVRs. There is something about the road presence and sound of cars like that that I will always keep being lured back to, but I see the 987 as probably the most balanced head vs. heart car decision I've ever made.