Regarding the EVO article, it does seem to have come down to subjective factors (although I have not seen the full article).  But EVO did print what they thought, and you have to give them some credit for that.  I do think that the "911 Beaten" cover story title was a bit provocative, chosen most likely to attract buyers.  But my guess is the Porsche will certainly be irritated by the results and the approach, and that EVO will be persona non grata at least in the short term.

Regarding other posts about buying a 997 GTS versus a new 991, there are surely some GTS bargains out there.  My dealer has no fewer than four on the showroom floor, and the pricing is attractive.  I would not choose the GTS over the 991, but certainly understand it is a great car and bargain now.