I'm all for comparing the Cayman and the 911 - it's only natural to do so.

We compare the 911 (in various forms) to the F360, F430, Gallardo, Vanquish, etc. They are all similar and yet very different, and it's fun to compare and we all have our opinions about which one is "better".

Why not do the same with the 911 and the Cayman S? Coming from the same manufacturer, it makes even more sense to compare them, since price, reliablility, ease of service, daily driveability can all be more closely compared.

I know RC and others have thought it was getting out of hand, but really, only one person became too emotional about it. There are plenty of threads where one person gets too emotional.

I think comparing the Cayman an the 911 makes a huge amount of sense and I for one would like to hear more adult opinions on the matter . . . good or bad either way. That's what this forum is about isn't it?