Auto Bild: test Nurburgring
BMW M6 8:07,76
Lamborghini Gallardo SE 7:56,65
Mercedes CLK DTM AMG 7:56,50
Porsche Carrera GT 7:39,49
http://www.autobild.de/test/neuwagen/artikel.php?artikel_id=11043&artikel_seite=0
Quote:
The Hawk said:
Bentley Continental GT 8:40,30
BMW M6 8:07,76
Lamborghini Gallardo SE 7:56,65
Mercedes CLK DTM AMG 7:56,50
Porsche Carrera GT 7:39,49
http://www.autobild.de/test/neuwagen/artikel.php?artikel_id=11043&artikel_seite=0
Quote:
nberry said:Quote:
john999s said:
Depends who's driving, weather, traffic....
Which only proves what many of us on this Board have been claiming regarding Ring times. WORTHLESS!
Quote:
MKSGR said:Quote:
nberry said:Quote:
john999s said:
Depends who's driving, weather, traffic....
Which only proves what many of us on this Board have been claiming regarding Ring times. WORTHLESS!
In case of the sportauto supertest you always have:
- the same driver (HvS)
- no traffic (as they rent the ring for their test events)
The weather is also no relevant factor as they state the weather conditions (air and ground temperature etc.) in detail.
Thus, sportauto supertest ring times a VERY RELEVANT BENCHMARKS![]()
Mar 25, 2006 6:17:34 PM
Quote:
MKSGR said:Quote:
nberry said:Quote:
john999s said:
Depends who's driving, weather, traffic....
Which only proves what many of us on this Board have been claiming regarding Ring times. WORTHLESS!
In case of the sportauto supertest you always have:
- the same driver (HvS)
- no traffic (as they rent the ring for their test events)
The weather is also no relevant factor as they state the weather conditions (air and ground temperature etc.) in detail.
Thus, sportauto supertest ring times a VERY RELEVANT BENCHMARKS![]()
Mar 25, 2006 6:46:31 PM
Mar 25, 2006 7:04:59 PM
Quote:
Crash said:
This mystery is easily explained.
To quote Sport Auto on the SE test:
"Die kürzere Getriebeübersetzung wirkt sich kontraproduktiv auf die Rundenzeiten in Hockenheim aus. Der Gallardo SE war im Test dort langsamer als ein normaler Gallardo E-Gear.
Außerdem wurde das Einkuppeln entschärft. Kunden hatten sich darüber beschwert, dass der Gallardo E-Gear zu scharf anfahren würde (typische Automatikkäufer - was suchen die eigentlich in einem Sportwagen ?!). Als Reaktion programmierte man das E-Gear so um, dass die Kupplung nun beim Anfahren stark schleift. Im Ergebnis beschleunigt der Gallardo SE mit 520 PS so schnell der Gallardo mit 500 PS. Den SE gibt leider auch nicht mehr mit der manuellen Handschaltung. Heutzutage will jeder per Knopfdruck am Lenkrad schalten, weil ja auch Michael Schumacher... dabei fährt Schumi in seiner Freizeit am liebsten Motorrad und läuft Ski... also nix Halbautomatik."
In essence, they state that the gearing is counterproductive in that the car accelerates no faster than a standard Gallardo, but turns slower times at Hockenheim. Add to that the fact, that it's over half a second slower than the 500 HP Gallardos, with the exception of one, which was obviously a weak car.
Gallardo acceleration times:
Standard Gallardos
Test in ams 23/2003
Gewicht 1612 kg
0 - 80 km/h 3,3 s
0 - 100 km/h 4,2 s
0 - 120 km/h 5,6 s
0 - 130 km/h 6,3 s
0 - 140 km/h 7,3 s
0 - 160 km/h 9,0 s
0 - 180 km/h 11,1 s
0 - 200 km/h 13,8 s
Supertest in sport auto 12/2003
Gewicht 1613 kg
0 - 80 km/h 3,2 s
0 - 100 km/h 4,0 s
0 - 120 km/h 5,4 s
0 - 130 km/h - s
0 - 140 km/h 6,4 s
0 - 160 km/h 8,4 s
0 - 180 km/h 10,1 s
0 - 200 km/h 13,0 s
Test in Auto Bild Tuning 04/2004
Gewicht 1640 kg
0 - 80 km/h - s
0 - 100 km/h 4,5 s
0 - 120 km/h - s
0 - 130 km/h 6,5 s
0 - 140 km/h - s
0 - 160 km/h - s
0 - 180 km/h - s
0 - 200 km/h 13,8 s
0 - 250 km/h 23,0 s
Test in Auto Zeitung 08/2005
Gewicht 1580 kg
0 - 80 km/h 3,2 s
0 - 100 km/h 4,2 s
0 - 120 km/h 5,6 s
0 - 130 km/h - s
0 - 140 km/h 7,0 s
0 - 160 km/h 8,5 s
0 - 180 km/h 11,1 s
0 - 200 km/h 13,3 s
Test in sport auto 07/2005
Gewicht 1636 kg
0 - 80 km/h 3,3 s
0 - 100 km/h 4,4 s
0 - 120 km/h 6,0 s
0 - 130 km/h - s
0 - 140 km/h 7,8 s
0 - 160 km/h 9,9 s
0 - 180 km/h 12,0 s
0 - 200 km/h 15,4 s
Gallardo SE
Test in sport auto 11/2005
Gewicht 1640 kg
0 - 80 km/h 3,3 s
0 - 100 km/h 4,3 s
0 - 120 km/h 5,9 s
0 - 130 km/h - s
0 - 140 km/h 7,5 s
0 - 160 km/h 9,9 s
0 - 180 km/h 11,9 s
0 - 200 km/h 14,4 s
It does not surprise me at all, that the car is slower at the Ring. Acceleration times that are worse than the standard Gallardo, coupled with badly thought-out gearing would seem to account for the 4-second difference.
Another one of Nick's brilliant theories shot down![]()
Mar 25, 2006 7:15:04 PM
Quote:
nberry said:Quote:
john999s said:
Depends who's driving, weather, traffic....
Which only proves what many of us on this Board have been claiming regarding Ring times. WORTHLESS!
Mar 25, 2006 9:17:50 PM
Quote:
nberry said:
Crash based on your response if the basic gallardo is faster in acceleration and faster in Ring time over the SE which is the same car but lighter and more hp what is the point of the SE? Did Audi build a dog to sell to the public fraudulently claiming it has better performance than the base model?![]()
Or are you totally confused by the GERMAN magazine numbers which are biased toward German cars? The Gallardo is still considered an Italian car in germany.![]()
Quote:
JimFlat6 said:
Amazing AMS! They get the only dog Gallardo SE on the planet! Woof woof! Germany calling!![]()
When they start to test cars scientifically, then their tests will be more than just fuel for ego debates.
And, I want to know just exactly why the Germans are not testing cars scientifically? !!!!!Thier numbers are not alles ordnung!
AMS get well soon!
![]()
![]()
![]()
Quote:
nberry said:Quote:
MKSGR said:Quote:
nberry said:Quote:
john999s said:
Depends who's driving, weather, traffic....
Which only proves what many of us on this Board have been claiming regarding Ring times. WORTHLESS!
In case of the sportauto supertest you always have:
- the same driver (HvS)
- no traffic (as they rent the ring for their test events)
The weather is also no relevant factor as they state the weather conditions (air and ground temperature etc.) in detail.
Thus, sportauto supertest ring times a VERY RELEVANT BENCHMARKS![]()
Same driver has little value. If I drove my 430 around the Ring faster than a 997TT (which I also drove) would you accept the 430 is a better performing car? I doubt it.
Quote:
nberry said:
Crash based on your response if the basic gallardo is faster in acceleration and faster in Ring time over the SE which is the same car but lighter and more hp what is the point of the SE? Did Audi build a dog to sell to the public fraudulently claiming it has better performance than the base model?![]()
Or are you totally confused by the GERMAN magazine numbers which are biased toward German cars? The Gallardo is still considered an Italian car in germany.![]()
Quote:
JimFlat6 said:
No,thats not the point at all. I want useful information,
not specious tests that are useless for any real data.
I could careless if a Opel had better times than a Ferrari, but in AMS that could happen Im sure!
I want to also know vehicle history, mileage and tire data along with track surface conditions.
Also how many of these cars are also inspected for factory alignment specs or to see if the car has been corner balanced?
Its up to AMS to inspect and certify that the cars tested are what you would buy at a dealership and not tweaked by Dieter, Larry, Suji or Gino! Otherwise, AMS is knowingly or unkowingly misrepresenting a cars performance.
Without them representing the cars candidly and accurately, they are really little more than Auto Motor und Casino with HvS as the croupier.
It is so stupefyingly easy to tweak and prep a car for a magazine test.You can do so with no internal mechanical or electrical mods and still get quicker lap times than a new car from a dealer that has a dead stock set up.
That alone should be caveat enough about automobile tests.
Quote:
Walter said:
"Otherwise, AMS is knowingly or unkowingly misrepresenting a cars performance."
That's why I like to compare the results from different magazines of different countries.If you did the same,you would notice that nearly every magazine is biased towards Porsche...Japanese,Italian,French,etc.
Quote:
MKSGR said:Quote:
Walter said:
"Otherwise, AMS is knowingly or unkowingly misrepresenting a cars performance."
That's why I like to compare the results from different magazines of different countries.If you did the same,you would notice that nearly every magazine is biased towards Porsche...Japanese,Italian,French,etc.
![]()
![]()
How unfair!!!
![]()
![]()
![]()
Quote:
MKSGR said:Quote:
nberry said:
Crash the whole point of the SE was to improve performance over the standard Gallardo.
Crash already posted the technical explenation why the SE is slower than the old version. You just have to read his posts...