Quote:
deedee said:
Congrats RC!! What a beautiful piece of work.... Basalt blk is indeed a good choice.....
May I ask why you ordered tipS but not manual?
Although I think there have been enough controversial discussions about my choice, I try to explain in a few words:
I've chosen Tiptronic over manual because the new 997 Turbo has some sort of "networked" design where all black boxes communicate with each other and the Tiptronic is part of it. Regarding REAL LIFE performance, this setup provides a huge advantage over manual and you need to be an extraordinary driver to be able to achieve a similar performance with manual, not talking about straight line acceleration only which is better with Tiptronic anyway. Some people apparently didn't pay attention from the beginning when we explained that the Tiptronic on the new 997 Turbo can't be compared to the Tip on other current Porsche models. Not because it would be a different kind of gearbox but because none of the other Porsche models has PTM and an engine with VTG chargers. Apparently this is something difficult to understand
for some people, I liked the comment "why doesn't the GT3 have Tip if it is that good...".
The problem with people reading this forum is that some are owners, some are not and some want to be owners but own a different car right now. This means that we have a mix of opinions, half-truth gathered from other forums and sometimes even false information, collected from the press, other car forums and even dealers. To cope with this "mix" of sometimes contradictory information isn't easy at all, not only because we have strong personalities and Egos involved but because even if we clarify a thing or two with an extensive explenation, it gets lost in the many threads and posts. The FAQ is a good place to start but I wasn't able to finish it since my real life job and the family have priority.
And a last "problem" we have: since we can't unveil our sources or tell everything we know in detail, we sometimes have a very hard time to explain things without being able to use this confidential information. I know that some users sometimes provoke intentionally to get the last drop out of me and the other mods but this only makes us furious, this ain't a good method to achieve that extra info everybody is hoping for. Sometimes people just need to trust our claims, even if they are from time to time contradictory to the claims on other car forums or even in car magazines.
Btw: manual isn't a bad decision at all, I've chosen Tip for my car (the only launch car with Tip in Germany btw. and not without a reason) because I was looking for a new performance challenge, to get the max out of the Turbo. With manual, it wouldn't have been possible for ME anymore but I know it is difficult to understand. Just say to yourself that I'm nuts if this comforts you.