Dec 2, 2006 9:59:37 PM
- milkee1991
- Newbie
-
- Loc: usa
- Posts: 8, Gallery
- Registered on: Dec 3, 2005
Crown
Board: Porsche - 911 - 996
Language: English
Region: Worldwide
Close
CloseForum - Thread
Dec 2, 2006 10:41:42 PM
- Grant S.
- Junior
-
- Loc: Pennsylvania
- Posts: 105, Gallery
- Registered on: Apr 30, 2005
- Reply to: milkee1991
Re: realiability of 996
I have had no problems with mine. I bought at 32,000 miles, and now have 82,000. Runs like a charm. Just as long as you get one that's well documented, they are great. For the price, I don't think you can beat it. You'll read all the horror stories of the RMS problems, but I think it's blown way out of proportion.
Dec 2, 2006 10:50:34 PM
-
RC
- Rennteam Administrator
-
- Loc: Rennteam HQ , Germany
- Posts: 21622, Gallery
- Registered on: Mar 26, 2002
- Reply to: milkee1991
Re: realiability of 996
Quote:
milkee1991 said:
Hi fellow rennteam members. I would want to know if buying a 996 with high miles (60-80ish) would be realiable. What kind of problems would i be facing? How much are the maintanence services? Is it worth buying one still or should i just go and buy different car.
Just a first good advice: avoid cars from the first two model years.
To make it easier for you: get a 996 with the facelifted frontlights only (this is how the 996 was looking when they stopped production!).
Avoid cars which are equipped with rims sizes larger than 18'' (19'' and up), avoid cars which have been lowered more than 30 mm, avoid cars which have been used for track racing (difficult to tell sometimes, take an "expert" with you to check the car).
Also avoid cars which have been chip tuned, avoid cars with coilover kits and make sure that there isn't much aftermarket stuff on the car, better: nothing.
60-80 k miles are a bit too much for the M96 engine, personally I wouldn't buy a 996 with more than 50000 miles on it.
I'm pretty sure that our Users will tell you about typical issues but there aren't many.
Dec 3, 2006 10:43:34 PM
- J.Seven
- Expert
-
- Loc: Estoril , Portugal
- Posts: 1933, Gallery
- Registered on: Sep 16, 2002
- Reply to: milkee1991
Re: realiability of 996
Quote:
milkee1991 said:
Hi fellow rennteam members. I would want to know if buying a 996 with high miles (60-80ish) would be realiable. What kind of problems would i be facing? How much are the maintanence services? Is it worth buying one still or should i just go and buy different car.
I'm soryy to say this, but stay away from the 996 series. These cars are very prone to engines and gearbox are severe failures and problems
I've had a replaced engine on my 50000Km 996 3.4L. 10.000 euros bill including a new clucth. Two friends of mine had a their 996 and 986 S engines replaced too, it's a desgrace believe me.
Here's some links to 996 blown out engines and gearbox.
996 blow out with engine pics
My own engine blown out
996 Broken engine
996 engine failure
996 engine failure from 2002 MY
more
And more
Died 996 engine
996 with engine and gearbox replaced
Several 996 broken gearbox
986 Broken engine
Interesting read
5 RMS and three engines blown at the dealer. Read Scouser post. on this link. (pics)
Another comun 996 engine problem
Áfter reading your post I've made a 5 minures search over the biggest internet "used car for sale" site mobile.de, all cars are in Germany There are several 996 used for sale runing on their second engine and other's being sold with broken engine.
996 for sale with broken engine
Another 996 for sale with pictures of broken engine
If you make a search on mobile.de for used 996 cars , you'll find many engines replaced.
Here's a sad storie of a long term test made to a 2003 996 Carrera 4 S made by a known magazine. 996 car was fantastic on every aspects but had a blown engine that made the author questioned Porsche reliability.
When I had my engine replaced , on the day i went there to talk with Porsche tech, he had the nerve to show me a remanufacter 996 engine they had just received from Germany for a 996 Carrera from 2001 (oil in water another comun problem) and he told me "that's what your remanufacter engine will look engine would look"
Ever since 1997 the 986 and 996 have been blowing at a scary rate, and many more will explode thrue out the years, it's just a matter of time and kilometers before it happened.
I'm a Porsche lover and had a Boxter and 996 Carrera who gave me much pleasure to own, and the fact I had a blown out on the 996 and a replaced gearbox on the Boxster wont be the reason for me not to buy a Porsche, but never the Boxster and 996 series, 996 GT3 and 996TT apart, bacause those are among the best engines Porsche ever made, their base is the GT1 engine, the bullet prove engine
Re: realiability of 996
996/Boxster engines are known for their failures - if you buy one make sure it has an official Porsche warranty on it, this "should" cover the engine issues - however I read somewhere it is at the dealers discretion whether they replace the engine at all, with a new or reconditioned one... Call your local dealer and get something in writing if you can... Good luck!
Dec 5, 2006 10:44:44 PM
- J.Seven
- Expert
-
- Loc: Estoril , Portugal
- Posts: 1933, Gallery
- Registered on: Sep 16, 2002
- Reply to: milkee1991
Re: realiability of 996
Re: realiability of 996
well, all we know that the 996 series has an annoying dark background but among the whole world production, I guess over 160k units, are the number of failures so significant compared with other premium brands to state categorically "don't buy any 996 ever"?
greets
greets
Dec 10, 2006 10:27:37 AM
- Steve R
- Senior
-
- Loc: UK - Edinburgh
- Posts: 695, Gallery
- Registered on: Feb 17, 2005
- Reply to: milkee1991
Re: realiability of 996
I have to say if you are looking for reliability, the 996 Turbo, GT2 and GT3 engines are very reliable - they are based on a 993/964 block (early ones had this 964 stamped on them even) and were developed for the GT1 - a proper race engine.
If you have a warranty from porsche I would not worry - but if you plan to track at all the GT1 derived engine can stand up to a bit more abuse!
If you have a warranty from porsche I would not worry - but if you plan to track at all the GT1 derived engine can stand up to a bit more abuse!
Re: realiability of 996
Quote:
manu said:
well, all we know that the 996 series has an annoying dark background but among the whole world production, I guess over 160k units, are the number of failures so significant compared with other premium brands to state categorically "don't buy any 996 ever"?
greets
I don't think there are any official numbers by Porsche.
Personally, I haven't encountered any problems in my 2002 4S so far, now with 70k kilometers (45k miles).
Re: realiability of 996
Quote:
Fast Fred said:Quote:
manu said:
well, all we know that the 996 series has an annoying dark background but among the whole world production, I guess over 160k units, are the number of failures so significant compared with other premium brands to state categorically "don't buy any 996 ever"?
greets
I don't think there are any official numbers by Porsche.
Personally, I haven't encountered any problems in my 2002 4S so far, now with 70k kilometers (45k miles).
Fortunately there are many 996 owners very happy with their cars and never had any major problem, but it's obvious there is a flaw in these poor engines which makes the 996 a problematic purchase for those who want to have one, and know about this failures.
"What would you like to have for lunch sir?
Well, maybe a 996 engine please...
Would you like to have it toasted, blown or seized?"
"Please check our menu for a wider choice, we from 2.5L 2.7L, 3.2L, 3.4L and even 3.6L and just from 1997 to 2003 model year"
2002 carrera blow up
Another
J.Seven
Re: realiability of 996
Ok, with that offered menu I would rather a tuna sandwich please
All series have their inherent flaw, may be with the 996 increased production, yell voices have increased all around whereas the percentual failures have decreased compared to former series.
I figure the 996 purchase hint is, as RC said before, avoid the first MY's and even better buy a 02 in forward. Beyond this, is like another second hand buying: playing lottery, just ensure the buying before and after with the common pre-inspection and guarantee, once this done is a luck issue , no horror involved.
One more thing that took my attention is the RC's state of don't buy any over 80k km car and the limit fixed in 128 k km. This really scares me; one 3.6 litres 6 cilinders engine should hold up without probelms much more than this on a daily or civilize trip use, without tracking of course, and with the basic maintenance and cares.... I really would like to buy one but, are these engines SO crap?
As you say: just my 2 cents
greets and Merry Christmas to you all.
All series have their inherent flaw, may be with the 996 increased production, yell voices have increased all around whereas the percentual failures have decreased compared to former series.
I figure the 996 purchase hint is, as RC said before, avoid the first MY's and even better buy a 02 in forward. Beyond this, is like another second hand buying: playing lottery, just ensure the buying before and after with the common pre-inspection and guarantee, once this done is a luck issue , no horror involved.
One more thing that took my attention is the RC's state of don't buy any over 80k km car and the limit fixed in 128 k km. This really scares me; one 3.6 litres 6 cilinders engine should hold up without probelms much more than this on a daily or civilize trip use, without tracking of course, and with the basic maintenance and cares.... I really would like to buy one but, are these engines SO crap?
As you say: just my 2 cents
greets and Merry Christmas to you all.
Jan 30, 2007 9:24:48 PM
- connoisseur
- Senior
-
- Loc: Nebraska
- Posts: 752, Gallery
- Registered on: Jan 30, 2005
- Reply to: donkeyman
Re: realiability of 996
No the 996 engine is not crap. Yes they do have a rear main seal problem all the way through production. No this problem does not effect every engine. Yes I would buy at least an 02 or newer. Yes complete dealer service records are a must. Yes it is best if you can find a one owner and talk with the prior owner. Just as any exotic incomplete or missing records are a RED flag. Keep your money in your pocket and keep looking.
Feb 6, 2007 12:58:32 PM
- Fast Fred
- Junior
-
- Loc: Belgium
- Posts: 50, Gallery
- Registered on: Oct 20, 2005
- Reply to: connoisseur
Re: realiability of 996
Don't worry about reliability too much. This 996 4S (for sale in the Netherlands) has a stunning 274.000 kms on the clock :
http://www.reijnders-trading.com/product_info.php?cPath=1&products_id=102
http://www.reijnders-trading.com/product_info.php?cPath=1&products_id=102
Re: realiability of 996
Quote:
Fast Fred said:
Don't worry about reliability too much. This 996 4S (for sale in the Netherlands) has a stunning 274.000 kms on the clock :
http://www.reijnders-trading.com/product_info.php?cPath=1&products_id=102
I bet it's running on his third engine
By the way here's one more engine blown last month 996 engine blown out
J.Seven
Re: realiability of 996
my previous comments in this section about pdf files from various uk magazines seem to have been modded out, but i came across this websiterecently which gives a good overview of engine issues in general..
http://www.hartech.org/docs/buyers%20guide%20web%20format%20Jan%202007%20part%204.pdf
http://www.hartech.org/docs/buyers%20guide%20web%20format%20Jan%202007%20part%204.pdf
Forum
About Rennteam | Help | Terms of use | Privacy Policy | Support | Contact | Imprint | Archive
Powered by
Community
and
