Quote:
brunner said:
Seems like you're a homofobe... Not at all surprising from a guy who chooses Oprah's pet doctor as his idol.
Sep 26, 2005 10:54:07 AM
Sep 26, 2005 12:24:27 PM
Quote:To soon to tell with Kimi and Alonso. I thought Schumi took to many chances early in his F1 career. He wasn't always the racer he is now.
JimFlat6 said:
If Schumi had been driving for Mclaren this year he would have won the title easily, but he wasn't and didnt.
Neither Alonso or Kimi are phenoms like Clark, Stewart, Lauda, Prost and others were. Schumi is the greatest of them all and this year he has also been a gracious loser.
I doubt he bothers with "what IFs" of any F1 season.
Sep 26, 2005 1:04:39 PM
Sep 26, 2005 3:40:18 PM
Quote:
easy_rider911 said:
Guys,
I'm neutral here. For me, both Kimi and Fernando have been the standout performers in F1 this year. I would be happy if either of these 2 talented young drivers had won.
I must say that there is a crucial factor being glossed over here. The reason why the Renault has been so much more consistent than the McLaren has depended on how much each team has tried to get out of their respective engines. Pat Symonds (one of the head honchos at Renault F1) was quoted in Brazil as saying that Renault could easily have tuned their engine to produce 20 more hp which might put its performance at a similar level to the Mercedes Benz engine in the McLaren. However, he added that this would probably cause greater engine unreliability (which MB has suffered). Kimi may have the faster car but he has paid dearly for the balance McLaren have struck between power output and reliability/durability.
I must add that both Renault and McLaren have their own achilles heels. Fisichella and Montoya are talented guys who are less reliable under pressure. I've lost count of the number of times this season that Montoya has spun off through driver error which cost McLaren a 1-2 finish. Poor Fisichella's season has been all downhill since the first race he won.
Comparing Raikkonen with Montoya and Alonso with Fisichella shows you how the 2 leading drivers are so much better than their respective team-mates with similar machinery.
F1 is a world where the tiniest percentages make a huge difference. Ultimately 2 really good teams are still fighting over the Constructors Title right down till the end of the season. We can't ask for more drama than that. It beats the easy procession that Ferrari had to win both championships last year.
How the mighty are fallen.
Quote:
andrea said:
For me Alonso is a good driver, but not a champion.
Doyou remember last year???
Trulli was ahead of Alonso till half season, when he had to sign another contract.
suddenly, the car of trulli was broken every race....
Quote:
Dr. Phil said:
When all is said and done, and no matter how we each feel about who the right winner is: Let's hope for a fair and equal season next year, where the top teams can match eatchothers technical abilities and RELIABILITY, so we get a more fair picture of who is really the better driver.
Wishful thinking perhaps, since there have been very few seasons where all are equal and techical difficulties have not been crucial, but regardless of my subtle and almost unnoticable pro-Kimi anti-Alonso attitude, this season has been one where Mclarens extreme performance and lack of reliability have played an unusually big role.
I'm looking forward to a championship with lots of battles and drama on the track where the fastest man (not just fastest or most reliable car) wins.
...and of course I'm looking forward to having that beer with Carlos...and watching him choke on it as The Iceman crushes..oh no...here I go again..hehe.
Quote:
JimFlat6 said:
Dr. Phil, the ONLY BIG MONEY racing where the cars are really close matched up is NASCAR. F1 is just too cutting
edge with too much software and too many ways to goof. You will never get the teams to a standard engine,tires,brakes, chassis and downforce.
Good Luck with you Marriage to Kimi!
Oct 7, 2005 10:14:54 AM
Quote:
Zürich said:
Most of the technical problems McLaren had (during the race) were non-engine related.
Oct 7, 2005 10:32:05 AM
Oct 7, 2005 12:54:11 PM