I love both, really!

I have 75000 km on my Carrera S 20mm suspension now and the manual gearbox is just so so good and a joy to use, it has the short throw option which is just fantastic, it's so precise and mechanical in feel.

The one from the GT3 is harder and sometimes I screw up my heel and toe but when I get it right, it's so cool. It needs time to warm up.

I have PDK on the Turbo S and it's also amazing! first I thought I'd get bored but it's a pretty amazing piece of kit, I use the paddles from time to time but the software in sport mode is usually pretty bang on and in sport plus mode, it's just insane and only for the track or mountain roads.

I feel very lucky to own both systems as I really wouldn't know which one to prefer.